DO HISTORIANS LIE?

Rebecca West was not only a noted novelist and the author of the great travelogue, Black Lamb and Grey Falcon (my favorite, of all books), which explained the conditions that recently led up to Kosovo.

For her writings on the postWorld War II trials of spies, collaborators, and Nazi leaders, West was called, by her peers, "the best reporter of our time".

A few years ago, Bill Moyers interviewed Rebecca West on PBS. He asked her why, in her busy life, she took time off to cover The Nuremberg Trials. West replied that she felt she had to do it to get out "the truth" about this subject. Then she remarked, "Historians are such liars, you know."

Some time later, the famous writer of spy novels (and former "intelligence agent"), John Le Carré, was being interviewed by Robert MacNeil, still part of the PBS MacNeil-Lehrer Report. When the subject of history was raised, John Le Carré said, "History is the lie upon which historians find consensus."

I know that, in my own field (mathematics and physics), historians either lie ("sin of commision") or neglect ("sin of omission") WHAT ACTUALLY HAPPENED.

				See! See! The historian hyperbolic!
				Mad as mythorian with colic,
				He hath disavowed math
				And all that math hath
				Endowed for our great body politic.
				He shall be forgiven,
				His sic sins quite shriven:
				Getting high on a high colonic.(jh)